|
Ghent Neighborhood History
This information is taken from the Ghent
National Register Nomination form.
PRESENT AND ORIGINAL PHYSICAL APPEARANCE
The
Ghent Historic District in Norfolk is a small residential
neighborhood located within walking distance of Norfolk’s central
commercial core. Part of a late 19th- and early 20th-century
suburban land development, the district encompasses approximately
eighty acres in size. Since the early 20th century, the western
arm of Smith's Creek has been traditionally referred to as the
Hague.
Streets
are regularly laid out, blocks north of Pembroke Avenue follow a
simple grid plan. Blocks south of Pembroke Avenue lie in a
semicircular pattern
conforming to the curve of Smith's Creek. Two minor diagonal
streets, Drummond Place and Mill Street, serve to connect the
inscribed semicircular streets. Beechwood Place, a small park set on
axis with Colonial Avenue, is at the core of the district.
Southeast
of the district, the new Ghent pedestrian bridge (erected by the Norfolk Redevelopment and Housing Authority), replaces an
earlier vehicle crossing of 1890. Metal and wood benches and
electric lamps based on Colonial designs line the center of the
bridge. Though historically incorrect, similar lamps are placed
throughout the district in a lighting scheme sensitive to the
character of the neighborhood. Streetscapes are relatively free of
aboveground utility wires and allow unimpeded views of Ghent’s
distinct architecture.
Land
use within the Ghent Historic District is primarily residential.
Hospital facilities are located to the west between Fairfax Avenue,
Botetourt Street, and Mowbray Arch (Sarah Leigh Hospital and Eastern
Virginia Medical College). The District’s only church is the
Unitarian Church of Norfolk (formerly the Second Presbyterian
Church) at 737 Yarmouth Street. The Garrison-Williams School (419
Colonial Avenue) is the only private educational facility and is
located in a rehabilitated residence. The Chrysler Museum, Norfolk's
prestigious art museum, is located at the northeast corner of the
district at the east head of Smith's Creek.
Although
most houses in Ghent were designed as single-family dwelling units,
many have since been divided into duplexes and apartments. Three
large apartment houses were' built during the first quarter of the
20th century: (545 Warren Crescent, ca. 1925); the
Holland (Drummond Place and Botetourt Street, 1904), and the Mowbray
(714.Botetourt Street, ca. 1914).
Ghent
is a richly landscaped neighborhood.
In addition to tree-lined streets (including plantings from
circa 1890 and 1970), most residences are fronted by shrubbery, neat
lawns, and small flower gardens. Large trees with full branches line
both grass banks of the Hague providing color and shade and adding
to the park-like setting prevalent through most of the district. The
banks are partially lined with park benches and are a popular
recreational site for--residents, picnickers, and joggers.
Terminating both north ends of the Hague and Smith Creek are stone
and cement sea walls (1919, 1922). The northwest end of the Hague
hold's a small park lawn and benches, the whole set off by low stone
walls. Completing, the green belt around the Ghent district, park
lawns extend along the entire southern edge of Olney Road. Beechwood
Place is the remaining public green in the district; unfortunately
it stands neglected and overgrown, surrounded by an ivy-covered
chain link fence.
STATEMENT OF SIGNIFICANCE
The
decades between 1890 and 1930 were a time intensive land speculation
across America as witnessed by the large number of newly planned
residential suburban developments. These suburbs range in size from
five or ten blocks of residential development to completely planned
suburban communities providing commercial, recreational, and
educational facilities. Popular plans in this period include based
upon romantic landscape theories of A. J. Downing, Alexander Davis,
and Fredrick Law Olmsted (i.e., the exploitation of the natural
landscape, subdivision of land into large building sites and the
laying of roads in curvilinear patterns which appears to follow the
natural contours of the terrain); the continuation of the existing
grid plan with provisions for tree-lined avenues and regularly
placed parks; and, after the Chicago’s World's Fair of 1893, City
Beautiful plans based upon Beaux Arts theories '(i.e. grid plan
diagonally cut by broad avenues visually terminated by civic
buildings and monuments). By
1910 virtually every major American city could claim at least one
such suburban development.
The
Ghent suburb of Norfolk, Virginia, began its development in 1890
with most construction occurring between 1892 and 1907. Located
blocks west of Norfolk's present commercial core, Ghent originally
covered approximately 220 acres.
Although most of Ghent was laid along a standard grid plan,
the citing of the south section of the suburb by Smith Creek, and a
“Y” shaped inlet off the Elizabeth River, suggesting a different
planning approach. Marshlands
at this area were filled and the shoreline given a semicircular
shape. The resulting
street, Mowbary Arch, soon became the favored location for the
stately houses of Norfolk’s middle and upper-middle class
residents. Ghent’s
plan was not particularly innovative, but it successfully exploited
the area’s strategic waterfront location, providing views over the
creek to the grass banks on the opposite shore.
While Ghent originally covered more than thirty blocks in
area, the Mowbary Arch section displays the highest concentration of
houses built during the late 19th century.
This area is contained by Smith’s Creek and Onley Road, a
four-lane traffic artery connecting the two arms of the creek and
providing east-west access to downtown Norfolk.
Before
its late 19th century development, Ghent was large farm
taking in what was known as Pleasant Point.
In 1810, William Martin deeded his land to Jasper Moran. Tradition states Moran soon renamed the areas “Ghent” to
commemorate the signing of the famous treaty ending the War of 1812.
The conclusion of the war was great economic significance for
Norfolk, resulting in the reopening of sea-lanes after years of
embargo. In 1830, two
years following Moran’s death, Commodore Richard Drummond
purchased the plantation, retaining its name Ghent.
The area remained farmland until 1890 at which time the
Norfolk Company, a newly formed land company, purchased Ghent as a
speculative venture.
The
choice of Ghent by the board of directors as the site for their
investments was largely determined by three factors: 1) the
projected expansion of trolley car routes west of Smith’s Creek;
2) the recent construction of a toll bridge across Smith’s Creek
north of Duke Street (completed in 1887); and 3) the annexation in
1890 of Atlantic City site of Ghent farm as the sixth ward of
Norfolk. As an added
incentive for development of this area, the annexations legislation
specifically allowed for deviations from the Norfolk building code.
John
Graham, a civil engineer from Philadelphia, was contracted by the
Norfolk Company to lay out the new suburb. 8 His plan offered such
modern amenities of urban life as sewers, gas pipes, water mains,
paved streets, and granolithic sidewalks.
The street layout was conservative, following a grid plan
across the site. Only in the Mowbray Arch section (the historic
district) did Graham deviate from the grid to exploit the aesthetic
land-water relationship. The entire subdivision was traversed by
Colonial Avenue, which along with Mowbray Arch, was considered to be
one of Norfolk's most prestigious residential streets. All streets
were landscaped with silver maples and magnolias, though these have
mostly been replaced by water oaks and sycamores.
Work
on laying the streets, filling the marshland, and shaping the
shoreline of Mowbray
Arch into a smooth semicircle continued from 1990 through 1907. The
first house completed is said to have been built by John Graham in
1892 at 502 Pembroke. By 1893 only ten buildings had been finished
or were under construction. Among these are the Hardy-Twohy
residence (442 Mowbray Arch ca. 1893), the Richard B. Tunstall
residence (530Pembroke Avenue, ca. 1892-93), the Fergus- Reid
residence (325 Colonial Avenue ca. 1892-93), and the William H.
White residence (434 Pembroke Avenue, ca - 1892-93).
Lots in the Mowbray Arch area sold for $2,500 each in 1892
and 1893. Houses sold for up to $20,000.
With the expansion of trolley car routes to the suburbs in
1894, building in Ghent accelerated. By 1900 two trolley lines
serviced the area and. over one hundred houses had been completed
within the Mowbray Arch district alone.
Numerous churches had been or were being erected along nearby
Stockley Gardens, and new public schools were being planned. By
1905, development of Ghent was virtually complete.
The
majority of buildings erected in Ghent were detached, single-family
dwellings, although attached town houses stand at 510-516 Colonial
and 340-346 Fairfax avenues and scattered in the 400 block of
Mowbray Arch. In addition to private dwellings, three apartment
buildings appear in the Mowbray Arch area. The Holland Apartments
were constructed in anticipation of housing workers associated with
the Jamestown Exposition of 1907. Later apartments include the
Mowbray (ca. 1914) and the Warren (ca. 1930). The Leach-Wood
Seminary was the first private educational facility in the Mowbray
Arch area, moving there in 1900 (apparently located at 411 Fairfax
Avenue). The erection of the Sarah Leigh Hospital (Beaux Arts) on
Mowbray Arch in 1902 is further evidence 6f Ghent’s prosperity. A
fourth story and two wings have been added to the hospital, which
has remained in continuous operation to the present day.
The
genealogy of the Norfolk Company appears complex. The Norfolk
Company was a
subcorporation of Blake, Boissevain and Company, itself a merger of
Dutch, New York, and London interests. While the primary activities
of Blake, Boissevain and Company concerned the financing of
railroads in America it formed three subsidiary land companies to
develop land and industrial subcorporations. A major objective of
these subsidiaries, the Virginia Land Company, the Virginia
Investment Association, and the Consolidated Coal, Iron add Land
Company, was to develop lands from Norfolk, Virginia, to Columbus,
Ohio. In Norfolk, the local- subsidiaries were the Norfolk Company,
the Ghent-Norfolk Company and the Portsmouth Company.
Local members of the founding board of directors of the
Norfolk Company were Richard B. Tunstall, Alfred P. Thom, Fergus
Reid, C- G. Ramsay, Walter R. Taylor, and N. M. Osborne, most of
whom built houses for themselves and their families in the new Ghent
suburb.
The
developers retained the farmstead's name of Ghent because of its
historic and romantic European associations. Though no architectural
controls existed at this early date, many builders picked designs
thought to be suggestive of European architecture. Architects of
Ghent's Queen Anne houses undoubtedly
took inspiration from drawings by the English architect
Richard Norman Shaw, reproduced in popular architectural
publications. Further
attempts to solidify ties between Ghent, Norfolk, and its European
namesake occurred in 1897
when the western arm of Smith's Creek was christened
"The Hague." Ceremonies
at the renaming celebrations paid honor to the Dutch roots of the
Norfolk Company (i.e., Boissevain) and the parent company's early
representative to Norfolk, J. P. Andre Mottu. Even as late as 1911,
promoters sought parallels between Ghent and.
European prototypes. Referring to a proposed extension of
water vistas of the Hague the Norfolk city beautification commission
observed. “Already the driveway which is to be built on both sides
of the water has been christened 'Norfolk Way,' and in a few years
it ought to rank with Queen's Road of Bombay or the grand boulevards
of European cities where water and land have been made to meet so
attractively.
The
400 block of Mowbray Arch presented the most romantic view of Ghent
at the turn of the century. Embodying
the suburb's most appealing characteristics of water, greenery, and
European-inspired architecture, this view of Ghent was seized upon
by local land promoters, the board of trade, and the Chamber of
Commerce in their city booster efforts. This block was reproduced on
post cards and numerous trade and souvenir publications for tourist
and promotional consumption as representative of Norfolk's modern
housing. Accompanying
these views were captions extolling the area's beauty and the
modernity of the city's new sewer, gas, and water systems.
Contemporary
descriptions of Ghent note the area possessed, "Norfolk's
brand-newest, tastiest and costliest, most stylish and attractive
homes . The streets in this quarter, unlike those of its older
parts, are wide. The mansions, many of them, are palatial, and the
grounds, as a rule, are spacious and handsomely adorned with shade
trees and shrubbery . . . “ Elsewhere this article boasts,
“'Ghent' is the new swell district of Norfolk.”
As
such, the suburb attracted Norfolk's middle- to upper-middle-class
residents--its civic leaders, professionals, and businessmen. The
Mowbray Arch section was a favored location by members of the bar,
with over eighteen lawyers residing there by 1905. Most prominent
among these was Robert W. Hughes, United States District Court Judge
from 1874 to 1898 and a noted Norfolk lawyer. Among Ghent residents
active in Norfolk's political and administrative scene were James G.
Womble (Common Council, member of the Board of Directors of the City
Gas Company, Sinking Fund Commission), W. W. Vicar (Select Council),
W. P. Obendorfer (Select Council), T. S. Southgate (Common Council,
1st Vice President State Board of Trade), George Arps (Common
Council), Robert B. Tunstall (Common Council, Sinking Fund
Commission), William H. White (Vice President City Gas Company), and
Edward R. Baird (Sinking Fund Commission).
Railroad
interests were strongly represented. Peter Wright, Edwin C.
Hathaway, and Walter H. Doyle were all associated with the Norfolk
Railway and Light Company. Edwin T. Lamb, manager of the Norfolk and
Southern Railroad Company, lived at 423 Fairfax Avenue, and William
M. Whaley, president of the Roanoke Railroad and Lumber Company,
resided at 317 Colonial Avenue. Other prominent residents of Ghent
include Fergus Reid, president of the Norfolk and Portsmouth Cotton
Exchange; Frank S. Royster, president of the Atlantic Guano Company
and the Frank S. Royster Guano Company; Charles M. Barnett, consul
for Nicaragua, Colombia, and Costa Rica and director of both the
Virginia-Carolina Trust Company and the National Bank of Commerce;
Severn S. Nottingham, editor and publisher of the Norfolk Landmark;
and Herman L. Page, a leading Norfolk realtor.
Though
the majority of dwellings in Ghent were completed by 1907, improvements continued on the Hague
and Smith's Creek. In 1909 the city appropriated three thousand
dollars to purchase stone for the continuation of the western arm of
the Mowbray Arch sea wall. The western bulkhead of the Hague was
completed in 1919. The semicircular sea wall to the east was
finished three years later. The
last major project in Ghent evidencing its continuing prestige was
the erection of the Norfolk Museum of Arts and Sciences in 1933
(Peebles and Ferguson; and, Calrow, Browne, and FitzGibbon,
Architects).
Developed
in less than fifteen years, Ghent possesses a unique image of
consistent, well-designed architecture placed within an attractively
landscaped environment. Stylistically a 'wide variety of late
19th-century architectural styles appear with Dutch Queen Anne,
Colonial Revival, and Shingle Styles dominating. Buildings generally
conform to a uniform scale of 2.5 stories and are of brick
construction with occasional stone facades or brick with shingled
upper stories. Residences range from builder town houses to large,
detached architect-designed dwellings. Though presently only a few
buildings in the Ghent Historic District can be attributed to the
hands of a specific architect, it is believed many of the designs
came from the offices of the following Norfolk architects: Peebles
and Ferguson; Carpenter and Peebles; Charles M. Cassell; James
Calloway Teague; G. B. Williams; and George C. Moser.
Specific
buildings displaying noteworthy designs include the Fergus Reid
residence (325 Colonial Avenue, 1892); the Frank S. Royster
residence (303 Colonial Avenue, ca. 1900-02); the William H. White
residence (434 Pembroke Avenue, ca. 1892); the Richard B. Tunstall
residence (530 Pembroke Avenue, ca. 1892); the Robert M. and Robert
W. Hughes residence (418. Colonial Avenue, ca. 1895-1900), and the
William Tait residence (436 Mowbray Arch, ca. 1895). A large
Colonial Revival house from the 1930s is found at 535 Fairfax
Avenue.
Following
a period of decline after World War II, Ghent began to stabilize
during the early 1970s. The city declared Ghent as a code
enforcement area in 1962. Two years later Norfolk City Council
recommended that the Norfolk Redevelopment and Housing Authority
declare Ghent a conservation area. Since this date planning reports
concerning the future development of Ghent were filed by Harry Weese
and Associates (Ghent: Guidelines for Redevelopment, Chicago, 1974)
and the Norfolk Department of City Planning (Ghent: Proposed Zoning
for Historic and Cultural Conservation Zoning.) Norfolk, June 1.975
May 1976).
Efforts
by the Ghent Neighborhood League and the Norfolk Redevelopment and
Housing Authority have assisted in the rehabilitation of numerous
houses. Unfortunately in some rehabilitation cases, porches and
facade details were removed and aluminum siding installed. Several
houses divided into apartments during the mid-20th century have been
returned to use as single-family dwellings. Recent landscape
improvements include the planting of new trees along residential
streets and of new flower gardens fronting individual houses. Houses
along Olney Road were razed as part of the redevelopment project.
The lands they occupied
have been grassed and provide recreational park facilities.
No
longer functioning as a suburb, today Ghent provides intimate
in-town housing within walking distance to Norfolk's commercial
core. Its period architecture, tree-lined streets, and attractive
waterfront location combine to provide residents of Ghent with one
of Norfolk's most appealing residential environments.
DESCRIPTION
Contributing
to the neighborhood character, most dwellings observe a common
setback line from the street. Residences tend to be of brick
construction, occasionally with stone facing on the front façade.
Uniform scale is found across Ghent with 231 stories being
the average height. Notable exceptions are the Eastern Virginia
Medical College (four stories), the Sarah Leigh Hospital (four
stories), the Holland Apartments (three stories on a high basement),
and the Mowbray Apartments (four stories on a high basement). Of
these only the Eastern Virginia Medical College and additions to the
Sarah Leigh Hospital break from the pervading, turn-of-the-century
character of the district. This break is due not so much to their
height as to their large mass and lack of historic
detailing--elements incongruous with their more distinctive
neighbors. Similarly, buildings located across from Cheat on the
outer banks of Smith's Creek break from the scale and character of
the district.
Stylistically,
late Queen Anne Colonial Revival, and Shingle styles dominate.
Colonial Revival interpretations range from Georgian Revival
to Federal to Queen Anne/Colonial Revival. Gambrel roofs hinting at
Dutch Colonial influences are occasionally seen in the Ghent area.
Shingle Style houses are second in number to Colonial Revival
dwellings. Three Shingle Style houses, possibly by the same,
currently unidentified architect, exhibit large porches in a
first-story recessed entrance bay.
Typical Shingle Style houses in Ghent are of masonry
construction on the first floor with frame construction (shingle
sheathing) on the second and attic stories.
Other
styles randomly found in Ghent. include English Tudor, English Half
Timber, Italianate Town House, and Beaux Arts (Sarah Leigh
Hospital). The
remainder of Ghent's dwellings are-more difficult to classify as any
single style. These include numerous builder Colonial Revival houses
as well as residences suggestive of Dutch Queen Anne town houses.
As
part of the Norfolk Redevelopment and Housing Authority conservation
area, Ghent receives strong community support in its preservation
efforts. Numerous houses have been returned to single-family
residences, and the neighborhood has regained much of its earlier
character. Houses rehabilitated by the NRHA tend to display the
greatest exterior changes. These alterations are usually limited to
the removal of porches and the application of aluminum siding, not
in keeping with the historic character of the original design. This
detriment aside, the Ghent Historic District remains Norfolk's best
preserved, turn-of-the-century suburban development. Fully
exploiting its waterside location, the district retains its original
street fabric and its cohesive groupings of prodigious middle and
upper-middle class dwellings.
|